Two Black Cats

For those of you that don't know... we have one already. But today I thought I was hallucinating. I tossed a pillow at our cat, Puck (it's not mean if you know his personality) and he ran down the hall, I glanced over at the car seat to notice Puck was now under the ottoman sleeping. hmmm. How did that happen? Puck then rounds the corner with his tail puffed up and back arched. I'm seeing {DoUbLe}. There are now TWO black cats in my house. Hmm. How did this happen? Best I can figure is that I left with the kids this morning to run an errand and the cat must have come in the garage, then when I got home, into the house. BUT I didn't see either of those happen, and I tend to pay close attention when I'm coming in and going out of the house. And what are the chances that a cat identical to ours comes in??? Odd... and if you think it's odd reading it, just imagine being in my shoes - I REALLY thought I might be losing it!!! I'm not wanting to just throw a pure black cat back outside right before Halloween... any suggestions? Anyone want a {SuPeR} cute black cat? I want to keep him, but pretty sure the hubby wont go for that one. We now (at least temporarily) have two black cats.

OH! PS.... I know I promised pictures, I'll add some later today.

But this excitement has thrown off my afternoon.